Blair Loses Vote on Terror Detention Bill
 |
James Joyner | Wednesday, November 9, 2005 |
The House of Commons today voted down a Blair-backed proposal which would have allowed police to detain terrorist suspects for 90 days without charge.
Blair Suffers Major Defeat on Terror Bill (AP)
Prime Minister Tony Blair lost a crucial parliamentary vote Wednesday on sweeping new legislation allowing police to detain terrorism suspects for 90 days without charge â the first major defeat of his premiership and a serious blow to his authority. Instead, lawmakers, including some from Blair’s own Labour Party, voted for a maximum detention period of 28 days without charge.
Lawmakers blocked Blair’s original proposal by a 322-291 vote, and then approved the modified plan by an almost identical 323-290 vote. The prime minister had refused to compromise over his plan. Knowing the vote could the tightest of his eight years in office, Blair recalled two Cabinet ministers from overseas trips to shore up support.
What’s especially odd about this is that the Conservatives have managed to get a win by staking out a position well to the left of Blair and most of the Labour PMs. Indeed, I’m less surprised that a number of Labourites voted against the proposal than that almost all of the Tories did.
On substance, the outcome is a good one. Even in the case of accused terrorists, four weeks is more than long enough to suspend habeus corpus.
- None Found
- Barack Obama, Natural Born U.S. Citizen
- Supreme Court Made Supreme Error in Child Rape Decision
- McCain and Obama as Leading Men
- Bush: Skipping Olympics an ‘Affront’ to China
- Al Qaeda in Iraq Defeated?
- Caption Contest Winners
- National Mall Disrepair
- 10 Taliban Kill Themselves in Botched Bombing
- Poll: Third of Clinton Voters to Stay Home
- Jesse Helms Dead at 86
No argument from me on that one.
I understand that it's an easier position to take from my standpoint than Bush's or Blair's--they're held accountable for securing their nations--but principle has to trump security at some point.
Comments are Closed
Now if only George W. Bush agreed with that.