What We Can Learn from Iran
 |
James Joyner | Monday, April 14, 2008 |
Alex Tabarrok passes on word that only one country in the world has an adequate supply of donor kidneys for transplants: Iran. The reason? They allow compensation for donors.
The government pays donors $1,200 plus limited health insurance coverage. In addition, charitable organizations also provide renumeration to impoverished donors. Thus demonstrating that Iran has something to teach the world about charity as well as about markets. Will wonders never cease? Recipients may also contribute to donor renumeration.
While a little queasy about having desperate families bidding for organs, not to mention the theoretical possibility of incentivizing foul play, I’m inclined to support such a plan. I am, however, highly dubious of data coming out of totalitarian states. For that matter, I’m suspicious that if the Iranian government feels strongly enough about organ donation that they’re offering stipends, the degree to which potential donors have much choice might be somewhat constrained.
- FDA to Implement Gay Sperm Donor Rules
- 1 MILLION
- Edwards Took High Paying Job to Learn About Poverty
- The Dilbert Blog: Cartoonist Kills Thousands
- Obama Didn’t Return Donor Calls, May Have Lost Millions
- 9/11 Fund Was a Mistake
- Babies Skirt Campaign Finance Laws
- Diabetes Cure via Islet Cell Transplant
- Snuppy The Clone
- Democrats Fighting Over 2006 Strategy
Once you see someone die for lack of an organ, you get over any moral qualms quite quickly.
Incidentally the Iranians have also liberal laws about stem cell research, and have government-subsidized gender change operations.
Comments are Closed
Yeah, well, there seems something to the idea of there being such economic conditions that people need to sell Kidneys and whatnot to survive.
Necessity, it is said, is a mother.