If you "understand the rationale" for this decision, then you are about the only one. Your "understanding" lacks, like the Courts, indicates a total lack of common sense.

Please tell me a common sense answer to this,

Why should we in the US, recognize a group of terrorist who represent no country, are not a part of any army, wear no uniforms, and themselves did not sign on to the Geneva Convention, and commit outright murder of innocents.

To do so is complete insanity and the 5 Judges who made the terrorist a part of the Geneva Convention are about as un American as one can get.

These Judges are an illegitimate group of so called American and fully deserve to be named "The Bastards of America" throughout the country.

What I, and every America wants to see is the rationale for these 5 �Bastards of America� making them, Al Qaeda, eligible to the Geneva Convention.

Herb, Perhaps you should only speak for yourself, and not the rest of America. I, for one, understand the rationale behind the decision, and agree with it.

The SC did not "make Terrorist a part of the Geneva Convention", they simply stated that the US is bound by our obligations under that convention. I don't see what we lose by abiding by the convention besides a lack of the warm fuzzy feeling you get knowing we're drowning and electrocuting people. If we can survive Fascism and Communism while still maintaining our humanity, I don't see why we should let Islamists take that away.

We don't have to be like them to beat them.

In fact. Kennedy should have been impeached long ago when he "Violated the Law Passed by Congress" and signed by the President in the Schievo Killing Case.

Kennedy Has made himself one of the 5 "Bastards of America" by his decision to make Terrorist a part of the Geneva Convention.

What I, and every America wants to see is the rationale for these 5 "Bastards of America" making them, Al Qaeda, eligible to the Geneva Convention.