Comments on: Army’s Caleb Campbell Drafted by Detroit Lions

By: James Joyner

James Joyner — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 18:25:02 +0000

Army had three Heisman Trophy winners, Doc Blanchard (1945), Glenn Davis (1946), and Pete Dawkins (1958). But those guys went directly into military service and were unlikely to be drafted. Even Navy's Roger Staubach (Heisman, 1963), who went on to a Hall of Fame career in the NFL, served his five years. He was in fact drafted, but not until the 12th round.

Campbell is not likely as good a football player as any of those guys. But he's immediately eligible to play pro ball!

By: Dodd

Dodd — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 17:53:38 +0000

According to the NFLN guys on draft day, even at 218 Cadet Campbell is the highest drafted player ever from Army.

By: Steve Plunk

Steve Plunk — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 14:52:44 +0000

Jim T,

The "cooks and bookkeepers" statement was meant to illustrate that not all West Point grads go into battle. Indeed not all GI's go into battle either. There are logistical concerns that must be dealt with. One of those is recruiting. Obviously Army leaders decided this would be the best use of this soldier so why second guess them?

He is fulfilling his obligation by following the orders of his superiors.

By: Magnus

Magnus — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 03:51:42 +0000

I can't understand the rationale of people like Senior D and ESPN here. Senior D, if you and I have a contract pursuant to which you are to pay 300,000 for my house, and, a year into the deal, I freely offer to lower the total price to 200,000 if you will agree to let me stick a "sold by Magnus" in your lawn and use your name in my advertising, and you accept, would that be a problem? If not, why is it a problem here? This is a case of two freely contracting parties freely agreeing to a modification of their agreement in a way that each obviously believes benefits them. Its not like the young man got his education paid for and then announced he was gay just so he could get out of having to serve, for cryin out loud...

By: JimT

JimT — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 22:43:32 +0000

This kid wasn't to be a cook or a bookkeeper. He was selected to attend (arguably) the premier military academy in the world to be one of this nation's future military leaders. He received not only a free education at the tax payer's expense, but a monthly stipend. All under the assumption that this is what is required to produce the future leaders of the Army. He is not fulfilling his obligation...he is getting over. I don't care what the Supe says. Duty, Honor, Country (unless I can get a contract).

By: Steve Plunk

Steve Plunk — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 14:54:14 +0000

The Army needs cooks and bookkeepers abroad and stateside. If they think this Cadet can fulfill his obligation as a recruiting officer and NFL player then it is their decision to make.

He was drafted in the late rounds so he may not even make the team.

By: SeniorD

SeniorD — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 13:34:21 +0000

This is wrong on two counts:

1. The Cadet signed an agreement to serve his country for at least four (4) to five (5) years after graduation. Usually for Army graduates, that means being a Butter Bar Platoon Leader.

2. The rest of his classmates will be in the field learning how to lead men and women in combat. Cadet Campbell is doing nothing even close to that.

By: William d'Inger

William d'Inger — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 22:03:36 +0000

Why not just let the pro teams pay for the kid's education and call it even? Since the teams pay millions for a good player, let them drop a million on the service academy. Atheletes of that caliber are rare, so it's not like pro sports would make a significant dent in the officer corps.