working

POPULAR TAGS

 Outside the Beltway 

Op-Ed in Asharq Alawsat

David Perlmutter, Professor and Associate Dean for Graduate Studies & Research at the University of Kansas’s School of Journalism & Mass Communications, and I have written an op-ed on peace in the Middle East. The piece appears in today’s Asharq Alawsat. David is author of VISIONS OF WAR, blogs at PolicyByBlog, and was the author of a much-linked piece in Editor & Publisher on “fauxphotography”, Photojournalism in Crisis.

At my blog: For Middle East Peace: Both Sides Must “Drink Poison”

About the Author: Former US Foreign Service Officer serving predominantly in the Middle East. Probably best defined as an East Coast Conservative. After studying at Georgetown University's School of Foreign Service, I worked in the private sector, in newspapers, advertising, and retail. I joined the US Information Agency in 1979, studied Arabic and French, and had assignments in Tunisia, Egypt, Syria, Bahrain, the UK, India, and two in Saudi Arabia. I blog about Saudi Arabia, the importance of US-Saudi relations, and efforts toward reform in that country at Crossroads Arabia. I believe that Saudi Arabia is of critical importance to the US, not only for oil, but for political, diplomatic, and strategic security reasons. It is far too important to leave to ignorant or ill-informed commentary. I receive no Saudi funding for my work.
 
 
Related Stories:
    • None Found
 
Recent Stories:
| Subscribe to RSS Feed | Permalink | Send TrackBack
 
Comments
 

Congrats!

Posted by James Joyner | September 15, 2006 | 06:39 am | Permalink
 

Sir I agree with your article but you try to simplify the most complex issues shrouding the conflict. I feel strongly that Israel would sign up for this to have peace, however, you left out key people in the equation. First Hezbollah is like a dog belonging to Iran and Syria that bites your children. You send it over to your neighbors yard and feed it, promising to support it until it eliminates the neighbors. Then you will strike a deal that would benefit both parties. Hezbollah feels it necessary to continue until its objectives have been met. Can you imagine Iran and Syria giving the Hezbollah a place in their society? Hamas on the other hand has nothing to lose. Without Israeli support their would be no economic system. Even if Israel gave them land, they have no way of self support, therefore they will fight until they take Israel's land and support system. Palestinian leaders have only shown the plight of their people and have not acted to secure their own self reliance. The world has thrown money at this problem, but what has it bought?

Posted by Sal | September 24, 2006 | 12:47 pm | Permalink
 

I think everyone involved would end up losing something. Some would lose more than others.

The experience of the former "hard men" of the IRA and the various Protestant militias in N. Ireland is not very different from what you decribe for Hamas and Hezbollah. They had to give up their very reason for being, at least the violent part of it.

Some got on with life, putting down their guns and bombs and playing more productive roles in the province. Others, unable to do so, became common criminals, dealing in drugs, extortion, and general thuggery. Yet others couldn't bring themselves to even that and try to continue "the struggle" with whatever support they can find.

What also happened, though, is that the terrorism generally stopped. People were no longer afraid to go shopping or to a restaurant. Walls that divided communities started to come down. The crime problems were addressed by the poliice and the far smaller number taking part in terrorism have been gradually squeezed out of both power and their communities.

N. Ireland isn't problem free these days. There are still a lot of issues that are being worked out, but by generally peaceful means. There are still hotheads and irredentists, but the problems they create (as during the annual "Marching Season" are becoming lesser problems.

All of this is, to my mind, preferable to what currently going on in the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Posted by John Burgess | September 24, 2006 | 04:37 pm | Permalink
 

RSS feed for these comments.

Comments are Closed

 
Search OTB
Lijit Logo
OTB RSS Subscribers via FeedBurner

For Advertising Info, write
otb@blogads.com

ADVERTISERS

OTB MEDIA

MANzine logo

OTB Gone Hollywood

OTB Sports

Allie is Wired

ATLANTIC COUNCIL

New Atlanticist Atlantic Council Blog



Visitors Since Feb. 4, 2003

All original content copyright 2003-2009 by OTB Media. All rights reserved.