Turkish Troops Head Toward Iraq
 |
James Joyner | Monday, October 22, 2007 |
Turkey has begun massing troops for what seems an inevitable march toward war with the PKK rebels in northern Iraq.
Dozens of Turkish military vehicles loaded with soldiers and heavy weapons rumbled toward the Iraq border on Monday after an ambush by guerrilla Kurds that left eight soldiers missing and killed 12.
Iraq’s president said the rebels would announce a cease-fire later in the day. Turkey’s government, which has rejected similar announcements in the past, said the country will pursue diplomacy before it sends troops across the rugged frontier.
[...]
In Washington, the State Department said the United States has opened a diplomatic “full court press” to urge Turkey not to invade northern Iraq. “In our view, there are better ways to deal with this issue,” spokesman Sean McCormack said, stressing that the United States regards the the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, known by its Kurdish acronym PKK, as a terrorist organization.
But isn’t U.S. policy on attacks by terrorist organizations that the best course is a fast resort to overwhelming military power? That we don’t negotiate with terrorists?
About the Author: James Joyner is the publisher of Outside the Beltway and the managing editor of the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer, Desert Storm vet, and college professor with a PhD in political science from The University of Alabama. He lives just outside the Beltway in Alexandria, Virginia with his wife and infant daughter.
Follow James on FriendFeed | Twitter | Digg
- Turkish Troops Head Toward Iraq
- Turkey May Attack Kurdish Rebels in Iraq
- Pentagon Giving Turkey Intelligence on PKK
- Turkey Set to Invade Iraq? (Updated)
- Iraq Kurds Invade Turkey, Kill 17 (Updated)
- Obama Iraq Withdrawal: Read the Fine Print
- Decline of U.S. – Turkish Alliance
- Turkey Recalls Ambassador after House Genocide Resolution
- British Soldiers Can’t Wear Uniforms in Public
- Turks Continue to Seethe Over House Committee Vote (Updated)
- Nathalie Blanchard Facebook Smile Leaves Her Depressed
- Glenn Beck, Community Organizer
- OTB Latenight – Cherry Poppin’ Daddies
- Hacked Climate Scientists Emails Reveal Truth
- Obama, the Recession, and Polls
- Giuliani Running for Senate, Not Governor
- OTB Latenight – The Jesus & Mary Chain
- Fox Fake Crowd Videos
- Congress to Investigate Fake Districts
- Douthat Blogging Again
- third world county linked with Speak the Truth, Be Sent to Coventry...
- 123beta linked with Sept. 11 Attacks Not So Bad...
- Nuke’s News & Views linked with Top 20 Mike Huckabee Facts
- Diary of the Mad Pigeon linked with Synthetic Democracy: Associations and Social Capital in Virtual Worlds...
- The Amboy Times linked with Southern California Fires...
- Adam's Blog linked with Zero Tolerance Insanity
- Leaning Straight Up linked with The Plame (edited biased lying) truth...
- linked with
- Conservative Thoughts linked with The Violent Oppression of Women in Islam (video)...
- Stuck On Stupid linked with Hillary Rodham Clinton Reaches 50% Unfavorable Rating, Up From 46%
- Right Voices linked with Nostrildamus Convicts Blackwater of Tax Evasion..He Should Let The IRS In On It!
- Turkey Preparing for War « The Van Der Galiën Gazette
You'd think we'd be spending more time telling the Kurds to cough up the extremists rather than telling Turkey to not cross the border. I can't say that I blame Turkey for going in and getting them.
We should try to be consistent in our message about dealing with terrorists. Last year we fully backed Israel's attack against Hezbollah. This is going to blow up in our face because we are in fact being hypocritical when we tell the Turks they can't protect themselves.
I think the last PKK unilateral ceasefire, a couple of months back, was less than 2 weeks old before they broke it.
Regards, C
Wow ... what a depressing, solutionless, COMPLETELY FORESEEABLE consequence of invading Iraq this is turning out to be ...
The bottom line is that the peoples in the "Middle East" had their own interests and conflicts before Europe drew a bunch of lines on the map post-Ottomans, and that it's pure fantasy to imagine that those map-lines were going to hold those interests and conflicts in check forever. In retrospect, it's a marvel that "Iraq" lasted so long ... and might have lasted longer, had we not gone in & kicked the anthill.
Anderson, perhaps you can connect the dots for me between the invasion of Iraq in 2003 and PKK attacks on Turkish interests from bases in Iraq. The PKK has been doing that since the mid 1980's. There was a brief hiatus after the Turks captured Ocalan back in 1999 but it was just a hiatus.
Dave - let me take a stab at that.
The US invasion shored up Iraqi Kurdistan's de-facto independence. This and the protection provided by the northern no fly zone since Desert Storm allowed the PKK and other groups to establish bases for operations into Turkey. There's no reason to believe Talabani or Barzani doing anything to hinder the PKK, even though they pay lip service when denouncing terrorism. Thus, sooner or later the PKK would be emboldened to launch more attacks against Turkey. At least back when Saddam was in charge, I don't think the PKK had a free run of the Iraq-Turkish border.
This and the protection provided by the northern no fly zone since Desert Storm
That would have been my take. That is, I think that whatever additional activity there's been since 1992 could possibly reasonably be attributed to Iraqi Kurdistan's relative independence. The question then becomes what increment in activity by the PKK can be attributed to events since 2003. I doubt it's very much.
So, if the complaint is that we should have left Saddam Hussein in Kuwait, I think we should be ready to entertain that idea.
If Turkey can make a run into Iraq to clean out PKK then why can't Iran logically do the same? Or the reverse, can't US make a run into Iran to eliminate sites where enhanced IEDs are made, stored, and then smuggled into Iraq? Not securing borders is a recipe for escalating tensions between nation states. Someone needs to get a handle on PKK if its not too late.
This validates the argument that we should invade Iran immediately.
Do as I say, not as I do.
DOUBLE STANDARD:
Why do we call it "War on Terror" when it comes to us and Israel, yet call it "Invasion" when it comes to Turkey?
Didn't we support Israel when it invaded Lebanon and killed so many people? Why don't we support Turkey in this case?
We went after Al Qaida because of their deadly attack in 9/11, which killed 3,000 innocent people in our soil. PKK killed more than 40,000 people in Turkey's soil and yet to be stopped.
Aren't we hypocrites?
