Twin Survives Abortion, Mother Suing

Mother sues NHS after twin survives abortion (Sunday Times of London)

A MOTHER who underwent an abortion after learning that she was pregnant with twins is suing the NHS for £250,000 after one of the babies survived. Stacy Dow, who was 16 when she found out that she was pregnant, is seeking compensation and damages for the “financial burden” of raising her daughter. Miss Dow, whose father has had to take on a second job to help to pay for his granddaughter, is claiming for “loss, injury and damage” suffered at the hands of Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust.

The teenager, who hoped to train as a nurse, decided to have an abortion as soon as she discovered that she was six weeks pregnant. Days later the procedure was carried out at Perth Royal Infirmary, where doctors advised her that no live material was left in her uterus. When Miss Dow started to put on weight and her periods stopped, she assumed that it was because of the contraception injection she had been given. The hospital had told her that possible side-effects included weight gain and an erratic menstrual cycle. Miss Dow said: “After 33 weeks I went to the GP and he told me I was pregnant. I thought he meant I had fallen pregnant again, and I couldn’t believe it when I was told that it was one of the original pregnancies.”

Miss Dow̢۪s daughter, Jayde, who is now a healthy three-year-old, weighed 6lb 2oz when she was delivered by Caesarean section on August 30, 2001, at the same hospital in which her mother had had the abortion seven months previously.

This could have been even more horrific, had Jayde been damaged during the failed abortion. While one sympathizes with Dow’s surprise and the strain an unplanned pregnancy put on her career plans, it’s hard to understand a mother suing because her three-year-old is not dead.

The fact that she was pregnant at 16 and just presumed she was pregnant a second time 33 weeks later does not speak well for her, either. “Fallen pregnant,” indeed.

FILED UNDER: General,
James Joyner
About James Joyner
James Joyner is Professor and Department Head of Security Studies at Marine Corps University's Command and Staff College and a nonresident senior fellow at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer and Desert Storm vet. Views expressed here are his own. Follow James on Twitter @DrJJoyner.

Comments

  1. Frank says:

    Great point, I was blogging about the story, found your comments, so I included your posts and a link to your site on my blog post. Great stuff.

  2. Tales of the Hideously Sad
    Via OTB: Twin Survives Abortion, Mother Suing.

    James Joyner has a lengthy excerpt and a link to the actual story via the link above. The basics: a 16 year-old in Britain had an abortion, but it ends up that they only terminated one of two babies….

  3. Twin Survives Abortion
    When God creates a life, He has a Plan for that life, and man should not interfere with that Plan

  4. Actually,
    I think this is an entirely appropriate thing to sue over, if one must sue over anything at all.

    I rather suspect that I'm swimming against the tide on this one, but so be it.

  5. thomas says:

    I thought they figured out what caused that pregnacy thing years ago?

  6. Wrongful Life
    What do you do when you’re 16 and pregnant with twins, have an abortion, and then find out months later you’re about to have a baby because one of the fetuses was missed during the abortion? You sue. A…