Fisking Sully

Stephen Green delivers an excellent fisking of Andrew Sullivan‘s endorsement of John Kerry. Excerpting line-by-line analysis of excerpts seems pointless, so go read it yourself.

I would add two things to Stephen’s analysis.

First, Andrew is being disengenous about his primary motivation, which he hardly mentions: Bush’s lukewarm endorsement of a constitutional amendment to maintain the traditional definition of “marriage.” My strong guess is that, had Bush not done that, the other things Andrew cites would not be enough to make Andrew endorse a liberal Democrat.

Second, Andrew contends that Bush isn’t really a conservative and therefore doesn’t deserve the support of conservatives. That’s an obviously silly argument, however, in the world of practical politics. Ronald Reagan is no longer with us. In reality, conservatives have two choices: George W. Bush and John F. Kerry. Period. No candidate more conservative than Bush is an option for 2004. Period.

On none of the issues Andrew mentions, save gay marriage, is Kerry closer to his preferances than Bush. Given that the effort to amend the Constitution on this issue have already failed and the momentum on the issue is moving entirely in Andrew’s favor–and that Kerry is only barely closer to his position than is Bush even on this one–it hardly seems worth electing a candidate who will nominate pro abortion judges to the Supreme Court and pursue even more of the expensive social programs that have Andrew in an uproar.

FILED UNDER: Blogosphere, Campaign 2004, National Security, , , ,
James Joyner
About James Joyner
James Joyner is Professor and Department Head of Security Studies at Marine Corps University's Command and Staff College and a nonresident senior fellow at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer and Desert Storm vet. Views expressed here are his own. Follow James on Twitter @DrJJoyner.


  1. Legal XXX says:

    Andrew Sullivan Has Jumped the Shark
    He’s long been the erratic and over-emotional drama-queen of the pro-war right, and it was only a matter of time before his own juvenile rhetoric and “analysis” caught up with him–but it’s official: Andrew Sulivan has jumped the shark.

  2. Now he’s really gone and done it
    The drawback of wearing your heart on your sleeve (or your blog) is letting your emotions take you somewhere you don’t want to go in public. Case in point: Andrew Sullivan’s virtual endorsement of John Kerry, apparently motivated by the…

  3. The Madness of Mr. Sullivan
    A roundup of blogosphere commentary of Andrew Sullivan’s delusions of conservatism

    My goodness. Andrew Sullivan has the audacity to dare explore other options in the wake of what he believes are major problems in the Bush administration!! The Earth has come to a screaching halt!! Andrew Sullivan is probably one of…