Friday, July 31, 2009
I think Joni’s earlier version is better, at least I like her voice better in this earlier version, probably because that’s the voice I always remember. She was much younger and so was I:
BTW, there’s a website called “Savedvid.com” that will allow you to download youtubes to your harddrive. I’ve only encountered one youtube that I couldn’t dl–Ryan Bingham’s “Bread and Water.” I used savedvid to get my favorite Joni song, a live version of “Nights in the City.”
Didn’t know she did an earlier version. I know she wrote this, bit didn’t Judy Collins have the hit with it?
I interviewed Collins, years ago on the Talk radio outfit I was with at the time. Sadly, we never got much into the area of Joni’s writing. She was in town for a concert with a local philharmonic and most of the material as I recall leaned twenty the classical. In reality, her tastes in music were all over the board.
As for Mitchell, Her tastes were also varied… a little more varied than “court and spark”, for example, would have let on. Look at the difference in sound between that album, let’s say, and “Blue”, which is a personal favorite of mine. (I will never understand why “How do you stop” wasn’t a major single)
I suppose her latest…(“Shine”, recorded about a year and a half ago) would be another datapoint along that line, (She covers “Big Yellow Taxi”… The Original on 1970’s “Ladies of the Canyon” so a direct a to b comparison is possible) though frankly I don’t have a copy of Shine. Yet.
I like her voice on this one, She’s aging just like those of us who enjoyed her for years. I’m well over sixty and just savor the living in this version. “I was a free man in Paris . . .”
Girl sounds like she’s been drinking plenty of whisky and water and hanging out in smoky jazz clubs.
I like the voice, but somehow dragging it out the way she does here makes the song sound as banal as it was.
Sort of like “Memories” from Cats.
As for Mitchell, Her tastes were also varied
I’ll say. Your comment reminded that she’d collaborated with Charlie Mingus (!) shortly before his death. Her wiki page gives a nice snapshot of her musical geography.
Make a one-time donation
Donald Trump Meets With Joni Ernst As Veep Search Continues
Tom Harkin: Joni Ernst “As Good Looking As Taylor Swift”
Joni Ernst Wins GOP Senate Primary In Iowa
Representative Mitchell Disaffiliates with the GOP
Edgar Mitchell, Sixth Man On The Moon, Dies At 85