Spammer Sentenced to Nine Years in Jail

Jeremy Jaynes, the first to be convicted under a federal anti-spam law, was sentenced today to nine years in prison.

Judge Sentences Spammer to Nine Years (AP)

A man convicted in the nation’s first felony prosecution for illegal spamming was sentenced to nine years in prison Friday, but the judge postponed the sentence while the case is appealed. Loudoun County Circuit Judge Thomas Horne said that because the law targeting bulk e-mail distribution is new and raises constitutional questions, it was appropriate to defer the prison time until appeals courts rule.

Jeremy Jaynes was convicted in November for using false Internet addresses to send mass e-mail ads through an AOL server in Loudoun. A jury had recommended the nine-year prison term. Virginia, where AOL is based, prosecuted the case under a law that took effect in 2003 barring people from sending bulk e-mail that is unsolicited and masks its origin. Prosecutors said Jaynes used the Internet to peddle sham products and services such as a “FedEx refund processor.”

I live right up the road from AOL and used to pass them on my way to work every day until I changed jobs.

One suspects that the constitutional arguments here will fail. The obvious claims are under the 1st and 8th Amendments (and, by extension, the 14th). Jaynes could argue that his free speech rights are being violated here.

The courts have been very stingy in protecting commercial speech, especially those that impose externalities on others. Indeed, until fairly recently, commercial speech was deemed to be uncovered by the 1st Amendment, period.

I’m less familiar with 8th Amendment jurisprudence but would think it would be hard to convince a judge that a nine year sentence for one of the most prolific spammers constitutes “excessive” punishment. The courts have applied a proportionality test in such cases. Given the number of offenses here, nine years seems quite reasonable.

FILED UNDER: Law and the Courts, Science & Technology
James Joyner
About James Joyner
James Joyner is Professor and Department Head of Security Studies at Marine Corps University's Command and Staff College and a nonresident senior fellow at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer and Desert Storm vet. Views expressed here are his own. Follow James on Twitter @DrJJoyner.

Comments

  1. Ed says:

    I’ll be happy when I see the first blog spammers go to jail.

  2. bithead says:

    Basics;

    The constitution applies to the government.
    Not to servers and systems and networks which are owned by private companies.

  3. white pebble says:

    Bad day to be a spammer!
    But a good day for the rest of us!

    :radar:
    Outside The Beltway : Spammer Sentenced to Nine Years in Jail
    Jeremy Jaynes, the first to be convicted under a federal anti-spam law, was sentenced today to nine years in prison….

  4. James Joyner says:

    Bithead: Um, this is a criminal charge? It’s the government that’s doing the punishing here.

  5. Eric Rudolph pleads guilty to all charges in exchange for life instead of death
    Eric Robert Rudolph, accused of the Centennial Olympic Park bombing nine years ago, along with two other bombings in metro Atlanta and one in Birmingham, has agreed to plead guilty to all the charges against him in exchange for a…

  6. Spammer gets 9
    Is 9 years excessive punishment for a spammer? That’s what the first spammer ever convicted of sending such time-and-resource-wasting material through e-mail is getting, although the sentence will await further appeals.

    Judge sentences spammer to n…

  7. Judge Sentences Spammer to Nine Years
    I hope we see many more of these convictions in the future. I think this is something all of us can agree with.

  8. Spammer Goes to Slammer
    Outside the Beltway reports on the nine years in prison that await a spammer. Somehow, I don’t think this is going to reduce the amount of spam in my inbox….