Inventing outrage in an already outrageous world.
CNN enterprise writer John Blake examines “What’s ‘digital blackface?’ And why is it wrong when White people use it?“
Perhaps you posted that meme of supermodel Tyra Banks exploding in anger on “America’s Next Top Model” (“I was rooting for you! We were all rooting for you!”). Or maybe you’ve simply posted popular GIFs, such as the one of NBA great Michael Jordan crying, or of drag queen RuPaul declaring, “Guuuurl…”
If you’re Black and you’ve shared such images online, you get a pass. But if you’re White, you may have inadvertently perpetuated one of the most insidious forms of contemporary racism.
You may be wearing “digital blackface.”
I’m pretty sure I’ve never shared these memes but I’ve certainly seen them shared. How, you might be asking yourself, does sharing a meme constitute “blackface”?
Digital blackface is a practice where White people co-opt online expressions of Black imagery, slang, catchphrases or culture to convey comic relief or express emotions.
These expressions, what one commentator calls racialized reactions, are mainstays in Twitter feeds, TikTok videos and Instagram reels, and are among the most popular Internet memes.
Digital blackface involves White people play-acting at being Black, says Lauren Michele Jackson, an author and cultural critic, in an essay for Teen Vogue. Jackson says the Internet thrives on White people laughing at exaggerated displays of Blackness, reflecting a tendency among some to see “Black people as walking hyperbole.”
But these aren’t White people dressing up as Black to make fun of them. It’s literally images or videos of actual Black people. And, with the possible exception of Wilkins, extremely successful celebrities at that.
If you’re still not sure how to define digital blackface, Jackson offers a guide. She says it “includes displays of emotion stereotyped as excessive: so happy, so sassy, so ghetto, so loud… our dial is on 10 all the time — rarely are black characters afforded subtle traits or feelings.”
Many White people choose images of Black people when it comes to expressing exaggerated emotions on social media – a burden that Black people didn’t ask for, she says.
“We are your sass, your nonchalance, your fury, your delight, your annoyance, your happy dance, your diva, your shade, your ‘yaas’ moments,” Jackson writes. “The weight of reaction GIFing, period, rests on our shoulders.”
Michael Jordan is one of the most admired people on the planet. The “Crying Jordan” meme derived from his induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame. It’s mostly used to troll those who lose an athletic competition.
I don’t know that anyone thinks of Jordon, Bank, or RuPaul as “ghetto.”
Some may say posting a video of Sweet Brown saying, “Oh Lord Jesus, it’s a fire” is just for laughs. Why overthink it? Why give people yet another excuse for labeling White people racists for the most innocuous behaviors?
But critics say digital blackface is wrong because it’s a modern-day repackaging of minstrel shows, a racist form of entertainment popular in the 19th century. That’s when White actors, faces darkened with burnt cork, entertained audiences by playing Black characters as bumbling, happy-go-lucky simpletons. That practice continued in the 20th century on hit radio shows such as “Amos ‘n’ Andy.”
Put simply: digital blackface is 21st-century minstrelsy.
“Historical blackface has never truly ended, and Americans have yet to actively confront their racist past to this day,” Erinn Wong writes in an academic paper on the topic.
“In fact, minstrel blackface has emerged into even more subtle forms of racism that are now glorified all over the Internet.”
Wong says that digital blackface is wrong because it “culturally appropriates the language and expressions of black people for entertainment, while dismissing the severity of everyday instances of racism black people encounter, such as police brutality, job discrimination, and educational inequity.”
This is, frankly, absurd. It’s true that all manner of racial injustice exists. Or, hell, injustice, period.
This is probably the meme I’ve seen most in recent years:
I’ve probably seen it captioned hundreds of times, making light of myriad controversies. Just about every time, the plight of poor folks in Appalachia—not to mention starving children in the developing world—was ignored. Because people make jokes about things without considering every other thing all the time.
Indeed, the overwhelming number of popular Internet memes feature white people. With perhaps the exception of Wilkins, the handful that feature Black faces lack anything that could reasonably called a “minstrel” quality. For example, I’ve seen these two quite often (much more than I have the Wilkins meme):
Neither is making fun of Black people.
This one, on the other hand, might be:
I’ve seen it many times and assumed it was from a movie. According to the above-linked Pocket-Lint post,
This is a meme known as “Roll Safe” or “Think about it” which is based on a screenshot from 2016’s Hood Documentary series on BBC Three which shows a man knowingly pointing at his head while justifying poor decisions.
These are essentially daft, but amusing, life hacks where “thinking about it” can be enough to justify poor life choices.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen it in a context where it came across to me as racialized. As with Morpheus (Laurence Fishburne) meme, the Blackness of the character is irrelevant to the joke/observation.
Alas, Blake explains, defining “digital blackface” is challenging.
In trying to define digital blackface, it depends on who you talk to. The standard for some is comparable to what one Supreme Court Justice once said when asked his test for pornography: “I know it when I see it.”
This guidance might help: If a White person shares an image online that perpetuates stereotypes of Black people as loud, dumb, hyperviolent or hypersexual, they’ve entered digital blackface territory.
And yet even with that definition, it’s hard to figure out exactly what is and isn’t digital blackface.
This is the challenge that Elizabeth Halford faces.
Halford, a brand designer, wrote an apologetic essay in 2020 about how she made a meme out of Wilkins’ “Ain’t nobody got time for that” catchphrase and sent someone a GIF of the singer Beyonce repeating, “I’m not bossy, I’m the boss.”
“I’ve engaged in digital blackface,” Halford wrote.” I’ve laughed at people of color on the news facing horrifying crime and disaster and loss. I’ve appropriated Black trauma as punchlines and peeled their faces off to put on my own and say what I can’t say, to make you laugh, or just because it went viral.”
Honestly, that sounds more like someone got hit by a social media pile-on and responded with a mea culpa written by a PR person. Beyonce is one of the richest, most powerful women on the planet; I don’t know that anybody thinks of her as loud, dumb, or hyperviolent. Her sexuality is doubtless part of her appeal but that’s hardly uncommon in the entertainment industry.
Halford tells CNN she was bothered that she overlooked the context of Sweet Brown’s interview. The woman had just experienced a tragedy.
“I guess we find it funny, the way (Black) people tell their story with so much flair,” she says. “but at the end of the day, one woman’s apartment building burned down while she was in bed.”
So, that’s fair! But I would wager that, 99% of the time, memes are divorced from the circumstances in which they arose. I have no idea what the origin of the Drake meme is and didn’t know until reading about it this morning that the “looking back boyfriend” was literally a stock photo that somebody meme’d.
But Halford says that doesn’t mean she won’t use any more GIFs of Black people. She doesn’t object to the Beyonce “I’m the boss” meme because she thinks it empowers women. She says that as long as a meme or GIF “is empowering and not demeaning” she feels free to use it.
Besides, Halford says, if she refrains from using any Black memes, she runs into another problem:
“Those are the most effective, because White people are so boring,” she says.
You’re not helping, Liz.
Jackson, in her Vogue essay, acknowledges it can be hard to know where to draw the line.
“Now, I’m not suggesting that white and nonblack people refrain from ever circulating a black person’s image for amusement or otherwise…” she writes. “There’s no prescriptive or proscriptive step-by-step rulebook to follow, nobody’s coming to take GIFs away.”
But no digital behavior exists in a deracialized vacuum, she says. A White person can spread digital blackface without malicious intent.
“Digital blackface does not describe intent, but an act — the act of inhabiting a black persona,” she adds. “Employing digital technology to co-opt a perceived cache or black cool, too, involves playacting blackness in a minstrel-like tradition.
“No matter how brief the performance or playful the intent, summoning black images to play types means pirouetting on over 150 years of American blackface tradition.”
This is utter bullshit. Black culture, and certainly Black pop culture, is inextricable from American culture. Black athletes, movie stars, and performers are as woven into our narrative as their White counterparts.
The above image, of the late Gene Wilder as Willy Wonka, is widely meme’d. Is circulating these anti-Semitic? Digital Jewface?
As to the meme referenced above that I find most problematic:
Another challenge with defining digital blackface is that some of the alleged victims of the practice might chafe at being labeled casualties of racism.
Consider what happened to the woman now known as Sweet Brown after she went viral. She hired an agent and appeared on “The View” and “Jimmy Kimmel Live.” An Auto-Tuned version of her original video now has at least 22 million views.
Sweet Brown did go public with accusations that she had been exploited. But it had little to do with her race.
Is Sweet Brown the victim of digital blackface? Or did she benefit from the exposure?
Those are not, of course, mutually exclusive options.
It’s a tough question. But in the meantime, if you are a White person who is contemplating using a “hold my wig” GIF, you should consider the advice Jackson offers in her Teen Vogue essay to White people who playact being Black online.
“If you find yourself always reaching for a black face to release your inner sass monster, maybe consider going the extra country mile and pick this nice Taylor Swift GIF instead.”
I’m not sure I’d be comfortable appropriating Swiftface.