RELIGION AND CIVILIZATION
Bernard Lewis has an interesting piece entitled, “I’m Right, You’re Wrong, Go To Hell” in the latest Atlantic Monthly. I read it in the print edition a couple of weeks ago, but it is just now available online. He contends that Christianity and Islam are the only two religions that define a civilization and argues rather persuasively that, while Christians can live with Islam, Islam can live with Christendom:
The Islamic world, with no comparable incentives, displayed a total lack of interest in Christian civilization. An initially understandable, even justifiable, contempt for the barbarians beyond the frontier continued long after that characterization ceased to be accurate, and even into a time when it became preposterously inaccurate.
It has sometimes been argued that the European interest in Arabic and other Eastern languages was an adjunctÃ¢€”or, given the time lag, a precursorÃ¢€”of imperialism. If that is so, we must acquit the Arabs and the Turks of any such predatory intent. The Arabs spent 800 years in Spain without showing much interest in Spanish or Latin. The Ottomans ruled much of southeastern Europe for half a millennium, but for most of that time they never bothered to learn Greek or any Balkan or European languageÃ¢€”which might have been useful. When they needed interpreters, they used converts and others from these various countries. There was no Occidentalism until the expanding West forced itself on the attention of the rest of the world. We may find similar attitudes in present-day America.
Today we in the West are engaged in what we see as a war against terrorism, and what the terrorists present as a war against unbelief. Some on both sides see this struggle as one between civilizations or, as others would put it, between religions. If they are right, and there is much to support their view, then the clash between these two religiously defined civilizations results not only from their differences but also from their resemblancesÃ¢€”and in these there may even be some hope for better future understanding.
Definitely worth a read.