Iraq War Over – We Won!

In case you missed the news, as I did, Andrew Bolt informs us that “The war in Iraq has been won.” You’d think somebody might have mentioned that before now.

THERE is a reason Iraq has almost disappeared as an election issue. Here it is: The battle is actually over. Iraq has been won.

I know this will seem to many of you an insane claim. Ridiculous! After all, haven’t you read countless stories that Iraq is a “disaster”, turned by a “civil war” into a “killing field”? Didn’t Labor leader Kevin Rudd, in one of his few campaign references to Iraq, say it was the “greatest … national security policy disaster that our country has seen since Vietnam”?

You have. And you have been misled.

Here is just the latest underreported news, out this week. Just 27 American soldiers were killed in action in Iraq in October – the lowest monthly figure since March last year. (This is a provisional figure and may alter over the next week.) The number of Iraqi civilians killed last month – mostly by Islamist and fascist terrorists – was around 760, according to Iraqi Government sources. That is still tragically high, but the monthly toll has plummeted since January’s grim total of 1990.

What measures of success do critics of Iraq’s liberation now demand?

Violence is falling fast. Al Qaida has been crippled. The Shiites, Kurds and Marsh Arabs no longer face genocide. What’s more, the country has stayed unified. The majority now rules. Despite that, minority Sunni leaders are co-operating in government with Shiite ones. There is no civil war. The Kurds have not broken away. Iran has not turned Iraq into its puppet.

And the country’s institutions are getting stronger. The Iraqi army is now at full strength, at least in numbers. The country has a vigorous media. A democratic constitution has been adopted and backed by a popular vote. Election after election has Iraqis turning up in their millions. Add it all up. Iraq not only remains a democracy, but shows no sign of collapse.

I repeat: the battle for a free Iraq has been won. Now the task is one familiar to every democracy, and especially any in the Middle East: eternal vigilance.

If you doubt my assessment of Iraq, ask Osama bin Laden. Al-Qaida’s media arm last week released a video on the internet in which bin Laden – or a man masquerading as him – revealed how disastrously his war against democracy in Iraq was going. He called for intensified fighting against the Americans and pleaded for Muslims in the region to come help. “Where are the soldiers of the Levant and the reinforcements from Yemen?” he demanded. “Where are the knights of Egypt and the lions of Hejaz (in Saudi Arabia)? Come to the aid of your brothers in Iraq.”

I do agree that there are positive signs, both militarily and politically. The Surge has been more successful than most of us had any reason to hope; then again, that’s not a high bar. But it’s one thing to say that things are moving in the right direction and quite another to say that victory is in hand.

Nor, incidentally, is this good news underreported. While it’s true that the press has over-emphasized the kinetic aspect of the war and largely ignored the logistical, the rise and fall of casualty figures, the purple fingered Iraqis lining up to vote, and other major milestones have certainly been given prominent attention. Indeed, the front page of today’s WaPo touts the declining casualty numbers, as does today’s NYT. But great news in Iraq has often been followed by an escalation of violence or a dramatic incident that results in a major setback.

AQI does appear to have suffered a major setback and violence is undeniably down. How much of that is a function of the brutal efficiency of ethnic cleansing and how much is a result of Coalition action is debatable.

Even our commanders aren’t quite ready to declare victory:

“This trend represents the longest continuous decline in attacks on record and illustrates how our operations have improved security since the surge was emplaced,” Lt. Gen. Raymond T. Odierno, the commander of day-to-day military operations in Iraq, said at a briefing for reporters. The momentum, Odierno said, was “positive” but “not yet irreversible.”

But Iraq defies sweeping statements about safety or danger. Both Iraqis and U.S. soldiers are wrestling with a basic question: Is the declining violence a lull in the war or the beginning of a long road to peace?

“My feeling is that this decrease in the violence is temporary,” said Saleh al-Mutlak, a secular Sunni who leads the Iraqi National Dialogue Front political party. “It’s temporary because the United States cannot maintain this number of troops in the areas where they are in. And if they do so, there will be no normal life in these areas.”

And, as a shopkeeper points out, the decline in violence is relative:

“The people used to talk all about ‘security is bad, security is bad,’ but in the past month, everywhere we go, everyone is talking about how things are improving,” he said. “Before the war, it was still much better than now. It has not gotten to that level yet.”

And it’s by no means over:

Even with lower casualty numbers, the quantity of violence indicates that militias and insurgents remain active in many areas. Large parts of southern Baghdad remain a battleground where U.S. soldiers, steadily encroaching Shiite militias and persistent fighters from al-Qaeda in Iraq clash. Attacks, unless particularly deadly, often pass with little notice outside the neighborhood in which they occur.

Many formerly mixed Sunni-Shiite areas have become largely the domain of one sect, since millions of Iraqis have fled their homes for other countries or other parts of Iraq over the years. “It’s much harder to conduct sectarian cleansing if you’ve got a homogenous neighborhood which has a local volunteer security force which is on the lookout for those people,” Miska said.

And, of course, there’s always the possibility of a Turkish invasion into northern Iraq.

I’m more optimistic than I have been in months that we can salvage a positive outcome from the fiasco that was post-invasion Iraq. But let’s not get ahead of ourselves in declaring victory.

FILED UNDER: *FEATURED, Iraq War, , , , , , ,
James Joyner
About James Joyner
James Joyner is Professor and Department Head of Security Studies at Marine Corps University's Command and Staff College and a nonresident senior fellow at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer and Desert Storm vet. Views expressed here are his own. Follow James on Twitter @DrJJoyner.

Comments

  1. Rodney Dill says:

    The way I read the excerpts it reads more tongue-in-cheek than as a serious declaration of victory.

  2. Patrick T McGuire says:

    What!? Does this mean that Harry Reid’s proclamation that “the war is lost” wasn’t true?

  3. Pug says:

    THERE is a reason Iraq has almost disappeared as an election issue.

    I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a better example of starting an essay with a false premise.

    Am I the only one who didn’t get the memo that the Iraq War is no longer an election issue?

  4. Mike says:

    Great we won – now cut the number of troops and let the Iraqis do something for themselves.

  5. Are We Losing Pakistan?…

    It appears so. The Counterterrorism Blog provides some interesting statistics.Two recent polls of Pakistanis show that between 60 and 76 percent of those polled seek the growth of Sharia throughout Pakistan, which is a key principle in political Islami…

  6. Jeff says:

    Nice to see someone reporting some good news. By the way, you might be interested in The Wounded Warriors Project. It’s a non-profit organization dedicated to raising awareness for U.S. troops severely wounded in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan. It really puts a face on the cost of this conflict. Here’s a link:

    http://www.woundedwarriorproject.org/aarwebs

    Jeff

  7. Grewgills says:

    THERE is a reason Iraq has almost disappeared as an election issue.

    What some have failed to notice is that the author of this statement is an Australian conservative.
    I am not certain that Iraq has “almost disappeared as an election issue” in Australia. If it has that probably has something to do with Australia only having on the order of 500 troops in Iraq. If we were down to 7-8K troops* in Iraq it would certainly fade as an election in the US as well.

    * an equivalent presence corrected for differences in population.

  8. Right Truth says:

    More Missile Defense Success…

    Northrop Grumman demonstrated several new air and missile defense battle management tools last month during a 10-day U.S. Army exercise focusing on net-centric upgrades to the Patriot missile communications system. (thanks to Peace and Freedom II) The …

  9. Iraq is Back in the News: The Tides Have Turned…

    Not death tolls because those are down. Not violence because that is down to the lowest levels. Not about IED’s because there is no news to reports about IEDS.The media has just noticed what we have been showing you for months… good news….

  10. Prozac Diaries: B. Hussein Obama Loves Those Crazy Iranians…

    The politics of appeasement. This would make Chamberlain proud
    Senator Barack Obama says he would “engage in aggressive personal diplomacy” with Iran if elected president and would offer economic inducements and a possible promise not to seek “re…

  11. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Random Yak, 123beta, […]

  12. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Random Yak, 123beta, […]

  13. Will Obama Give it Traction?…

    B. Hussein Obama has stated that Hillary is hiding behind her gender. Many have stated, I included, that the contenders would be cautious about attacking Hillary because they did not want to be perceived as picking on a woman. They all know how that …

  14. Wayne says:

    “THERE is a reason Iraq has almost disappeared as an election issue.”

    The reasoning behind that comment is that the Dems have gone from mentioning Iraq every few minutes to barely mentioning it at all.

  15. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, , Right Truth, […]

  16. Well, if you deny victory long enough, maybe your wishes will come true.

    Crittenden nailed it though, in response to the WaPo’s hesitancy in announcing Iraq progress (it’s a “lull” in the violence):

    This and other lull articles are lullabies for war opponents who might be alarmed at the prospect of a Bush victory, and the implications that could have for their own congressional and presidential aspirations.

    Might your post be in the same vein?

  17. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, The Random […]

  18. Sheriff Joe to the Rescue at the Palo Verde Nuc Site!…

    A DIFFERENT TAKEBy now everyone knows a contract worker drove into the Palo Verde Nuclear Plant today with ……

  19. IP’s Learn the Basics During 10-day Prep Course…

    This is a great article of accomplishment. I never believed in a huge central government, and I’m glad the Iraqis are finding it is within their own power to make their lives better. Ya know, after WWII, we DID write Japan’s constitution for them and…

  20. High School Reunions…

    I was listening to a song by Joe Walsh called “Class of ‘65” which is about him being invited to his class reunion which turns out to be more melancholy and emotional than he anticipated. This, along with some other things ongoing in my life, got…

  21. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight […]

  22. Pathetic Postings Today, Unicorns, Mangy Coyotes, and Volcanoes…

    FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 2I’ve had an “off day” two articles I’ve been working on most of the afternoon never panned ……

  23. PhotoHunt 82: Classic…

    The latest PhotoHunt category from tnchick.com is “Classic” which can be interpreted as one sees fit. This one is from my paternal Grandmother’s photo album which she gave to me several years ago. Yep, that’s me in the goofy outfit with the equ…

  24. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, , […]

  25. Phelps and Westboro Baptist ordered to pay millions to slain Marine’s Father: Suppression of free speech or just desserts…

    It is a serious question and one I am admittedly bothered by.  Let me explain, but first I want to make it clear that I abhor Phelps and his protests at Soldiers funerals, and his entire anti gay campaign.

    To be double clear, Phelps and his ch…

  26. Okay, I Think Phillip K. Dick Has Been Done to Death and We Can Move On Now…

    Bruce is a long-time science fiction fan and as a result he’s seen almost every movie based on a Phillip K. Dick story. This is no easy task, as Hollywood has done about 15 Phillip K. Dick movies and there are more in the works….

  27. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight […]

  28. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight […]

  29. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, , […]

  30. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight […]

  31. Lilian Ellison — (1923-2007) — R.I.P….

    I just learned of the passing of the Fabulous Moolah, the greatest women’s champion wrestler of all time. And probably one of the legitimately toughest women as well. On June 24, 1995, she was inducted into the WWF Hall of Fame, becoming the first fe…

  32. Motor Voter = Auto Fraud-o…

    I was never a big fan of the federal Motor Voter Act. But where I really came to despise it was in a county office in Meadville, Pennsylvania, where I applied for my marriage license not long after it took……

  33. President Reports Progress In Iraq…

    And I’m sure that there are plenty of folks out there who find it particularly galling that we are headed towards success in that country. President Bush offered an upbeat assessment on Friday of progress in Iraq, saying that while……

  34. Ted Nugent On Liberalism…

    Funny and apt adaptation of a fun Ted Nugent tune.
    ……

  35. […] Outside the Beltway: Iraq has been won, or so says Andrew Bolt (who OTB links to) […]

  36. WaPo Story Confirms No Dirt On Fred Thompson…

    After all, when the best you can do in scandal mongering is turn up dirt from the public record on a friend/adviser that is probably a good indication that there is no dirt on the candidate. Republican presidential candidate Fred……

  37. Is Feinstein Next?…

    And if she is, does this mean that the GOP may be able to pick up a California Senate seat? For the second time in recent months, Sen. Dianne Feinstein (Calif.) on Friday confirmed that she will break ranks with……

  38. Adam's Blog says:

    Compromising the Franchise…

    Tonight, we talk about how the franchise is being opened up to non-citizens including eight of the 9/11 hijackers and how vital the battle against illegal aliens having driver’s licenses is. (Hat Tip: Leaning Straight Up.)
    Other stories:

    The cr…

  39. […] to Hot Air, Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Midnight Sun, , , Right Truth, […]

  40. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, , , Right Truth, The Populist, […]

  41. Slick Hil: All Rhetoric, No Action…

    ……

  42. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, […]

  43. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, The Midnight Sun, […]