Bush Surging to Comeback?

Der Spiegel’s Gabor Steingart has written “The Comeback of a War President,” the first positive piece on President Bush I’ve seen (outside the usual suspects) since roughly since maybe the spring of 2005.

He may be America’s most unpopular politician, but George W. Bush is no lame duck. As a wartime president, Bush dominates the political agenda. He is discreetly influencing his party’s choice of presidential candidate while committing his country to an aggressive foreign policy, the effects of which are likely to continue well beyond his term in office.

The first sentence is obviously true, even if it goes against the conventional wisdom. That says little about Bush; it’s just the nature of his office. The second sentence, though, is a harder sell. Certainly, it conflicts with the wisdom of the recent “Most Influential American Conservatives” assessment.

Steingart makes two points in his defense:

First, there has been noticeable improvement on the Iraqi war front. Unless the Pentagon statistics Bush recited on Friday in a speech to soldiers at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, are made up, the new Iraq strategy appears to be working. The number of weekly bombing attacks on US troops has dropped by half, and the number of US military deaths is the lowest in a year and a half. At the same time, US forces are arresting or killing more than 1,500 terrorist “thugs,” as Bush called them, each month. If the military successes continue, public opinion toward Bush and his Republicans could soon improve. Americans are not against war itself, they just don’t like losing.

That much is more-or-less right. Whether because of the Surge or a combination of domestic factors, Al Qaeda in Iraq is on the ropes, casualties are down, and various other indicators on the security front are positive. And Americans desperately want to feel good about any war this costly, so they’ll naturally rally if the good news is sustained. None of that means that the war will be “won” under its original terms, though.

Second, Bush dominates his party’s search for a suitable presidential candidate, and he does so without voicing a preference for any of the candidates. Instead, he exerts control by dictating the job description. According to Bush, the right man for the job would not be an economic expert or a seasoned diplomat, but a sheriff, a man with nerves of steel, a man who can lead. Of course, for Bush being a strong leader means, first and foremost, leading the nation into war.

I’m much less sure of this piece. Yes, Bush is setting the stage for the foreign policy debate. It’s far from clear, though, that he’s getting his way.

Steingart continues:

The Bush agenda — wage war! — is the country’s agenda. His goal — victory! — sets the tone for the 2008 presidential race. And the mood he has created — fear of further terrorist attacks — has taken hold among the majority of voters. For the American public, even a narrow-minded view of reality is still a reality.

In this mood, Bush is driving the Democrats along like a sheepdog herding sheep. He asks for congressional approval for each new expenditure in his war, putting the Democrats in a difficult position. The US Senate recently approved a measure to designate the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps as a terrorist organization. Hillary Clinton reluctantly voted in favor of the measure. When Bush asked for tighter sanctions on Iran, the Democrats nodded grimly. While Bush looks at scenarios for attacking Iran, Senator Clinton, feeling the need to demonstrate her ability to lead the country in a war, insists that all options must remain on the table.

It’s true that “toughness” continues to be a rallying cry in presidential politics. The country is tired of war, though, and the overwhelming consensus of the foreign policy Establishment of both parties is against war with Iran. Indeed, thus far, Bush himself has been against said war, strong language about what’s “unacceptable” notwithstanding.

FILED UNDER: General, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
James Joyner
About James Joyner
James Joyner is Professor and Department Head of Security Studies at Marine Corps University's Command and Staff College and a nonresident senior fellow at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. He's a former Army officer and Desert Storm vet. Views expressed here are his own. Follow James on Twitter @DrJJoyner.

Comments

  1. 123beta says:

    Bush’s Resignation Speech…

    This is a nice find by ChrisCam (who got it from Common Sense and Wonder) ……

  2. yetanotherjohn says:

    Listen to the lament of the left about how little congress has done to “stop Bush” and you will see this. Failure to over ride vetos, try after try to attach a time table to Iraq funding, wire tap authorization law, etc havd gone Bush’s way. Given the popularity of Bush, you would think that the democrats would be scoring victories.

    The water bill is the first veto that he has lost. His plan for Iraq is what is being carried out. Even the democrat’s front runners are not talking about pulling all troops from Iraq anymore. For good or ill, Bush has set the agenda and that is what the country is following.

  3. […] Bush ain’t dead yet. While the public is dissatisfied with the way the country is going, whether it will vote in a presidential election the way the Democrats are going is not yet known. What Republicans seem to know better than Dems is that people vote their fears. If Democrats can’t get voters to fear future Republicans, they, not Bush, will look lame election day 2008. […]

  4. Benedict says:

    “None of that means that the war will be ‘won’ under its original terms, though.”

    James, what do you mean by this? Saddam is dead, and his Baathist power structure has been destroyed. Iraq has not dissolved into a 3 state confederacy. A constitution has been written and meaningful elections held (and seem likely to be held again). A multi-ethnic Iraqi Army is taking increasing control of security issues, etc., etc. While the time line might not have been what was originally anticipated, what other “original terms” of victory are out of reach?

  5. James Joyner says:

    While the time line might not have been what was originally anticipated, what other “original terms” of victory are out of reach?

    The whole democratic light that would shine on the whole Middle East and set off a cascade of imitators thing.

  6. Steve Plunk says:

    Maybe the democracy thing will take more time to prove itself, maybe it will never work. Either way it’s too early to call it dead.

  7. A culture of life?…

    Thank GOD that the state Supreme Court recognizes that a doctor’s mission is to promote life and not death. At least in this case….

  8. The Picture of Antioch College: A Tragedy of Manners…

    The beautiful campus and stately trees of Antioch College are the face of Dorian Gray, while the managerial, financial and educational disaster detailed in Charlotte Allen’s Death by Political Correctness, are the horrifying portrait hidden under…

  9. Is It Time for Chertoff to Be Stopped?…

    THE BLASTED BORDER FENCEONCE AGAIN CONSERVATIVES BETRAY THEIR VALUESThe thing I don’t like about this whole Homeland Security ……

  10. anjin-san says:

    First, there has been noticeable improvement on the Iraqi war front.

    No one doubts that our forces can defeat the insurgents in battle. And clearly, AQ in Iraq has overplayed it’s hand and lost much of the support it once enjoyed.

    But really, so what? Bush’s puppet government in Iraq is hardly functioning. It is certainly not making any progress twoards becoming a healthy, stable democracy.

    Much like in Vietnam, the regime is propped up by US military might. Without it to provide cover, the government in Iraq would not last a month.

    How much blood and national treasure will we sacrafice to prop up a government that cannot survive without the US Army standing in front of it?

  11. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, The […]

  12. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, guerrilla radio, […]

  13. Adam's Blog says:

    Abortion Lies v. Reality…

    Podcast Show Notes

    It turns out the liberal press exaggerated the number of illegal abortions going on within Mexico and as Jill Stanek reminds us, that’s the same type of deception that made legalized abortion possible in the US.
    While America…

  14. Alex Knapp says:

    It’s true that “toughness” continues to be a rallying cry in presidential politics.

    And unfortunately, Americans are a little fuzzy on the difference between being “tough” and being a bully.

  15. Video comedy break, Glenn Beck and Dennis Miller Style…

    Glenn has a little fun with NBC’s green week as he celebrates “Coal Week”

    In the second clip Dennis Miller takes on Global Warming.

     

    Thanks to Hot Air for the Glenn Beck clip.

    Trackposted to Outside the Beltw…

  16. Bithead says:

    The first sentence is obviously true, even if it goes against the conventional wisdom. That says little about Bush; it’s just the nature of his office. The second sentence, though, is a harder sell. Certainly, it conflicts with the wisdom of the recent “Most Influential American Conservatives” assessment.

    Not really, James. Perhaps it’s time that I reiterate what I’ve been saying for eight years now; George W. Bush , for all that he is, is no conservative. He is a centrist.

  17. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, The […]

  18. Dave Schuler says:

    Please support the use of the word “puppet” in reference to the Iraqi national government with documentation.

    I agree that the Iraqi national government is dysfunctional but I don’t think that’s because it’s a “puppet government”. Unfortunately, I think it’s because it accurately reflects the will of the Iraqi people and the Iraqis have deep internal conflicts.

  19. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, The […]

  20. […] Joyner at OTB: Der Spiegel’s Gabor Steingart has written “The Comeback of a War President,” the first […]

  21. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, […]

  22. A Tip for Hillary and Her People…

    There was a big deal made yesterday about Hillary Clinton not leaving a tip when she stopped for a meal and campaign appearance at some diner. The waitress mentioned it in response to a story about Hillary using that waitress and her life experience i…

  23. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, Right Truth, Leaning Straight Up, The Bullwinkle Blog, Big […]

  24. Bandit says:

    And unfortunately, Americans are a little fuzzy on the difference between being “tough” and being a bully.

    Speak for yourself as far as not knowing the difference – the rest of us are all set with it

  25. […] also: mixed blessings Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson’s Website, Rosemary’s Thoughts, […]

  26. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson’s Website, Rosemary’s Thoughts, […]

  27. Veterans’ Day Double Feature: “Reveille” and “American Soldiers ROCK!”…

    I first saw this video online several months ago and found it quite moving. From what I hear it may be made into a full length motion picture. I was reminded of this video due to Linkfest Haven having it on its website in honor of Veterans’ Day. I al…

  28. […] to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson’s Website, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Stix Blog, […]

  29. […] to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson’s Website, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, The Populist, […]

  30. […] also: mixed blessings Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, Stop the ACLU, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson’s Website, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Stix Blog, […]