Former Fla. Governor Charlie Crist Is Running For His Old Job, As A Democrat

Charlie Crist, and his tan, want the Governor's Mansion back.


To the surprise of pretty much nobody at this point, former Florida Governor Charlie Crist, who gave up the chance at what would have been an easy path to reelection in 2010 to run for Florida’s open Senate seat in 2010 only to be defeated in a three-way race by Marco Rubio, will be running for his old job as Florida’s Governor next year, this time as a Democrat:

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — As Charlie Crist, the newly minted Democrat and former Florida governor, sat outside his waterfront condominium here in his hometown recently, the “Go, Charlie” shout-outs never let up.

A Lincoln Town Car pulled up and Mr. Crist leaned in and shook hands, doing what he does best. “Hey bro, what’s happening?” the driver asked. “I’m good, man,” Mr. Crist replied. When a Duke Energy worker recognized Mr. Crist, the former governor gave him an earful about solar energy. “You got my vote, buddy,” the man said. “There’s our next governor right here.”

Whether Mr. Crist, a man who sprinted from Republican to independent to Democrat in three years, can wrest the governorship away from Rick Scott is anybody’s guess. But on Friday he filed his paperwork to run for governor. And on Monday, with the enthusiastic backing of most leading Democrats, Mr. Crist, 57, is expected to formally announce his intention to reclaim the governor’s office in 2014.

Mr. Crist’s announcement is all but certain to kick off one of next year’s most expensive, contentious and rancorous governor’s races, pitting betrayed Republicans out for revenge against hopeful Democrats out for redemption.

In an interview last week, Mr. Crist, who governed as a centrist from 2007 to 2011 before leaving after his unsuccessful bid for the United States Senate, said Floridians were “heartbroken” over issues like education, the environment, voter rights and Medicaid funding.

“I know we can right the wrongs,” said Mr. Crist, with his trademark tan and easygoing style. “I know it can be done. I know it in my heart. I know Floridians want it. They are very hopeful for a bright future. And I believe it’s coming.”

But, he said, he has no doubt about the intensity of the brawl that lies ahead: Governor Scott, a Republican and a multimillionaire, is expected to counter Mr. Crist’s charm offensive by focusing on claims that he helped turn around the Florida economy and raising a record $100 million to protect his job, a sum that he will begin spending on Monday when the first attack ads are scheduled to air.

“It’s kind of a daunting task to face,” said Mr. Crist, explaining why it has taken so long to come to a decision on the race. “It’s kind of like looking at a $100 million meat grinder, face first.”

Much of that money will be spent trying to portray Mr. Crist as an opportunist, a man willing to switch parties and positions on issues to suit his political ambition. Mr. Crist, as governor, fled the Republican Party in 2010 to become an independent after it was clear he would not win the Senate primary against Marco Rubio. Last year, he became a Democrat.

The Republican Party of Florida did not wait for Mr. Crist to join the fray. It began its assault weeks ago, highlighting his shift over the years on issues like gay rights and Obamacare. To that end, it opened up a Tumblr account and a Twitter feed titled “This day in Crist-ory.”

“Charlie had more positions than a gymnast,” said Rick Wilson, a Republican political consultant who once worked for Mr. Crist. “He will tell Democrats what they need to hear, and he will tell Republicans what they need to hear.”

But, Mr. Wilson added, Mr. Crist has “peerless skills in the actual game of politics,” which makes him a formidable candidate.

The campaign, one in which former foes are now friends and former friends are now flamethrowers, promises to be anything but dull. It comes ready-made with a history of slights and grievances on both sides toward both candidates.

And it undoubtedly will offer up a vivid contrast in personalities: one man a centrist and inveterate crowd-pleaser who sidesteps dogma; the other a Tea Party conservative, a shy executive who prefers to steer clear of prying eyes and cameras.

Mr. Crist also will face an already-declared candidate, Nan Rich, a former State Senate Democratic leader who reminds voters at every turn that she is a “lifelong Democrat.” But, after months of campaigning, Ms. Rich’s candidacy has not gained much traction.

For most Florida Democrats, any misgivings they may have had about Mr. Crist evaporated in a burst of pragmatism. Once Mr. Crist joined the party, he quickly became the most viable candidate to take on Mr. Scott and the conservative wing.

Crist’s political history is an interesting one to say the least. Had he chosen to, he could have run for reelection to a second term in 2010 at a point when his approval ratings were relatively high, even inside the party that would eventually reject him as a candidate for the U.S. Senate. Had that happened, he’d now be serving out the final year of his second term. Instead, he chose to toss his hat into the ring to fell the Senate seat vacated by the retirement of Mel Martinez where he ran headlong into the Tea Party onslaught and the candidacy of then Speaker of the Florida House of Representatives, Marco Rubio. Given his time in state politics, Rubio was far different from other candidates that Tea Party groups rallied around in 2010, but his generally conservative views, combined with the support he was getting from other nationwide Republicans due to his ties to Florida’s Latino community in general and Cuban-American community specifically, meant that the popular GoAdvernor would find the race far different from the one he was expecting.

After leading in the polls for awhile, Crist quickly fell behind Rubio. Rumors that Crist would drop out of the race for the GOP nomination started circulating as early as February of 2010, and though quickly denied, they became official in April. At the time, many thought that Crist’s decision would be beneficial for Democrats because it would divide an otherwise united Republican base. As the race picked up speed, though, polling showed early on that the race was really one between Rubio and Crist, and that Rubio ended up pulling ahead of Crist in the polls by early August. In the end, with Rubio beating Crist by nearly 20 percentage points, accounting for a margin of over 1,000,000 votes. The popular Governor had turned out to be a not so popular Senate candidate. To add insult to injury for Crist, he was replaced in office by the far more conservative Rick Scott and found himself out of a job. In subsequent years, he would endorse Barack Obama for President, speak at the Democratic National Convention and, late last year, officially become a Democrat himself. It’s been obvious ever since then that Crist was preparing himself for a bid to retake the Governor’s Mansion.

For all the bad luck he’s had over the past three years, this actually seems like a smart political move for Crist. As I noted, he left office a fairly popular Governor and would have easily won reelection in 2010 had he chosen to go that route. Polling earlier this year, such as that I wrote about here and here, showed him beating Governor Scott, who has not enjoyed the same popularity in office that Crist did during his era. So, it’s not at all inconceivable that Crist could win his old job back. There are several caveats, though. Scott’s job approval numbers have improved since those polls were taken earlier this year, and he’ll have access to the same vast personal fortune that allowed him to absolutely swamp Alex Sink in 2010. Additionally, the state of the race next year will depend very much on the state of the economy in Florida, which does seem to be improving. So, this will be one of the most interesting races to watch next year. Either Crist will make a big political comeback, or he’ll be defeated once again notwithstanding the fact that he’s in a different party now.

FILED UNDER: 2014 Election, Environment, US Politics, , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Doug Mataconis
About Doug Mataconis
Doug Mataconis held a B.A. in Political Science from Rutgers University and J.D. from George Mason University School of Law. He joined the staff of OTB in May 2010 and contributed a staggering 16,483 posts before his retirement in January 2020. He passed far too young in July 2021.


  1. Todd says:

    This will be an interesting real life test case for some of the issues discussed in those “what happened to the moderates” posts.

    Florida Liberals don’t like Charlie Christ because he used to be a Republican. Florida Conservatives can’t stand him, for essentially the same reason.

    The big question is, are there are enough voters in the middle for Charlie to get back to Tallahassee?

  2. rudderpedals says:

    @Todd: I’m certain the votes are there for Charlie for gov., who would have beaten stuffedshirt Rubio if it wasn’t a three-way race.

    I have yet to speak with an actual person FTF that has anything but contempt for Rick Scott. The only thing to distinguish one person’s opinion from another is the level of vehemence, but no one has anything good to say about him.

  3. Todd says:

    @rudderpedals: My mom is pretty active in Florida Democratic politics these last couple of years, and I can tell you that she’s no fan of Charlie Crist. Granted, you are correct, there’s no way she wouldn’t vote for virtually anybody who wants to replace Rick Scott. I just don’t think Charlie, if he is even the D nominee, is anywhere near as popular as he used to be. If he wins it would be much more about the fact that he’s not Rick Scott, than people actually wanting him back in the governor’s mansion. He’s a “hold your nose”, “lesser of two evils” type candidate.

  4. rudderpedals says:

    @Todd: Good on your mom for being active in the party. It’s a difficult and too often thankless activity. I shared her concerns about Crist until recently as he’s donned and touted new liberal clothing while working with John Morgan [a TV ad name down here, PI atty]

    We really don’t have a deep bench down here anymore outside of South Florida and bits of Orlando and around Tampa Bay. With McBride dead and his wife running for Ex rep Young’s seat (Sink) the viable gubernatorial choices are likely to be Nan Rich and Crist. Rich is a natural first choice policy wise but I don’t think she can win the name recognition game in time. Has your mother told you who if anyone she prefers over Crist?

  5. An Interested Party says:

    Better for Charlie Crist and his tan to sit in the governor’s office in Tallahassee than Rick Scott and his corporate sleaze…

  6. Moosebreath says:

    Is his tan running for Lt. Governor?

  7. superdestroyer says:

    It is not amazing that many former Republicans will move to being Democrats for political survival reasons but that how far to the left many of them will go once they make the switch.

    Maybe one of the many problems that the Republicans have is that many people in the Republican establishment are much more liberal than the rank and file Republican voter and thus identify much more with Democrats and Democratic Party voters than with Republican voters.

  8. Grumpy Realist says:

    Can I root for injuries? Or at least attacks by large spiders?

  9. fred says:

    He’ll replace our failed gov, Scott. Fl voters are going to clean house and turn our local and state govt blue. Most of us have had enough of the right-wing misinsormed and uneducated reps who some sent to our houses of govt.

  10. Tyrell says:

    I wonder if he joined the southern wing of the Democrat party, the party of Russell, Ervin, Mansfield, Long, Johnson, and Fulbright?
    “Help me, information, get in touch with my Marie, she’s the only one who called me here from Memphis, Tennessee” (Johnny Rivers, “Memphis”)

  11. John425 says:

    Dear Charlie, Arlen Specter is calling. Shall I put him through?

  12. rudderpedals says:

    ITYM Arlen Spectre

  13. An Interested Party says:

    Dear Charlie, Arlen Specter is calling. Shall I put him through?

    Awwww…a pity for Republicans that Crist’s situation is different than Specter’s…different in that Crist has a much better chance to achieve his goal than Specter did…