COVID Normalcy and the American Gerontocracy
Speaker Pelosi has it. Is President Biden next?
Wednesday, Steven Taylor noted that an outbreak among the elite guests at the Gridiron dinner demonstrates that COVID is not done with us. The Atlantic‘s Russell Berman has something of a follow-up in “A Push for Normalcy Tests the Gerontocracy.”
Yesterday afternoon, President Joe Biden hosted a good old-fashioned bill-signing ceremony at the White House. Before an audience of several dozen in the State Dining Room, the president celebrated the long-awaited enactment of a postal-reform bill. After his brief remarks, a large, bipartisan group of lawmakers crowded around Biden as he put pen to paper on the legislation. They huddled in close, as politicians do, silently jostling for prime position in the photo. None of them wore a mask, although House Speaker Nancy Pelosi carried one around her wrist like a handbag.
The event was a taste of the normalcy that Biden has been trying to create lately. Reality intruded this morning, however, when Pelosi announced that she had tested positive for COVID-19, becoming the highest-ranking government official to do so since former President Donald Trump’s near-death bout with the virus in October 2020. The 82-year-old speaker stood maskless right beside the 79-year-old Biden yesterday; she also attended an even larger, mostly mask-free event at the White House a day earlier that featured Biden and former President Barack Obama.
Biden’s own test came back negative last night, the White House said in a statement. Because he interacted only briefly with Pelosi at both events, he is not considered a close contact under the CDC guidelines. But that may be wishful thinking. The virus seems to be stalking the president: Two members of Biden’s Cabinet, Attorney General Merrick Garland and Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, tested positive after attending the annual Gridiron Club dinner on Saturday night, a gala that brought together several hundred members of the D.C. elite. The president’s sister, Valerie Biden Owens, also tested positive after attending the dinner.
Biden, who did not attend the Gridiron Club event, is going about his business this week, reflecting what he called the “new moment” that the country has entered in its fight against the pandemic. “We are moving forward safely, back to more normal routines,” the president said during last month’s State of the Union address. “COVID-19 need no longer control our lives.”
As he has throughout his tenure, Biden is trying to model the behavior the government is recommending. He’s fully vaccinated and double-boosted, having received an additional shot within days of their authorization for people over the age of 50 or who are immunocompromised. When the CDC urged wearing masks in public spaces, the president wore one except when speaking, to the point where Republicans mocked him for keeping his face covered while walking outside alone during trips between his helicopter and the White House. Now that the CDC has updated its recommendations, Biden is back to glad-handing in close quarters without a mask.
Yet the push for normalcy is complicated when the leaders doing the pushing are, according to the CDC, still at the highest risk of getting very sick or dying from COVID. People in Biden and Pelosi’s age group, 75-84, represent just 3.3 percent of COVID-19 cases recorded during the pandemic, but they make up more than one-quarter of all deaths. That older Americans comprise such a small portion of overall cases is likely because millions of them are long retired and interact with far fewer people than the president of the United States and the speaker of the House. (Both of Pelosi’s octogenarian lieutenants, Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, 82, and Majority Whip James Clyburn, 81, weathered mild COVID-19 cases during the winter Omicron wave.) With COVID cases rising again in more than half the country, including the District of Columbia, public-health experts are encouraging people at higher risk for severe COVID, including the elderly, to exercise more precautions. Can Biden do that while projecting “normalcy”?
Two-plus years into the pandemic, and more than a year into the vaccination era, I don’t see that he has any choice. During the campaign and his early presidency, he dutifully modeled responsibility—perhaps excessively so once he was vaccinated—in order to set the example. At this stage, he’s taking a slightly elevated risk to show Americans that it’s time to get on with their lives.
Now, I don’t think Pelosi should have been at the signing ceremony. Not because she’s geriatric but because she was sick. She should have quarantined herself. And, if the symbolism of watching Biden sign (checks notes) Postal Service reform? into law was somehow so important that she simply had to be in attendance, then she should absolutely have worn a mask.
Whether Hoyer, Clyburn, and the rest should all have retired long ago to pave the way for the next generation of leaders is, well, ultimately a question for the constituents who keep sending them back to Washington to decide. One presumes they have the good judgment to be vaccinated and boosted.
Regardless, the fact that we’ve pretty much ended widespread social distancing, masking, and other public-facing countermeasures in order to “get back to normal,” it’s inevitable that more White House and Congressional staffers and senior leaders—quite possibly including the President himself—will contract the disease. The point of being triple- and quadruple-dosed is that it should mitigate the effects substantially.